Hardik Pandya
Hardik Pandya. BCCI Photo

Did India commit a blunder by excluding Hardik Pandya from the Test squad?

3 mins read :

Few notable names were missing in India’s long squad for the World Test Championship final against New Zealand and the subsequent Test series against England. Apart from Bhuvneshwar Kumar and Prithvi Shaw who have had impressed recently with their performances, Hardik Pandya was a notable exclusion. Indian captain Virat Kohli had recently expressed that Pandya was crucial to India’s chances in Tests abroad as his all-round skills bring the X-factor to the XI.

But the selectors have omitted him out. So, was it a well-thought-out decision or a tactical blunder? CricChronicle takes a look.

Yes, it was the right decision

Hardik Pandya, the bowler, is not ready

Hardik Pandya – BCCI photo

Pandya had recently recovered from back surgery and has not bowled much in international cricket since his return. He did bowl in the limited-overs series against England at home. But he had hardly rolled up his arm over in the postponed IPL 2021. It is clear that Pandya, the bowler, is not ready to go through the grinds of Test cricket.

Hardik Pandya, the batsman, is not up to Test standards

And taking him purely as a batsman would mean benching a regular batsman. And it could be Hanuma Vihari whose superior technique and temperament are suitable for the longer version of the game. Besides, Pandya, the batsman, is yet to match up to Test standards on the seaming and fast tracks of England. Hence, until Pandya is fully fit as a bowler, his batting alone does not merit a place in the squad when there are better and technically equipped batsmen available.

Also Read  Steve Smith Praises Kohli, calls him "Simply Phenomenal."

But it could be a tactical blunder

Hardik Pandya provides the X-Factor with his batting

Hardik Pandya – Photo courtesy: Outlookindia.com

Thanks to Rishabh Pant’s fearless batting, India won the Test series in Australia and the Test series against England at home recently. Hardik Pandya does bat the same way and could take the attack into the opposition camp with his counter-attacking batting style. Hence, India could miss another ‘intent’ lower-order batsman who could not only score runs but at a brisk pace too.

He could bowl in short spells, giving respite to main strike bowlers

Although Pandya may not be able to bowl long spells needed in Test cricket, his short spell of few overs could just be the respite main strike bowlers could ask for. Besides, Pandya is also a wicket-taking bowler. In the last Test series in England in 2018, Pandya returned with a five-wicket haul in the only Test India won. And hence, India could miss the services of a pace-bowling all-rounder in England.

Backups to Pandya may not be enough

Shardul Thakur seems to have been chosen ahead of Pandya as a pace-bowling all-rounder after the former impressed in the Test series Down Under. But would Thakur match up to expectations? Thakur is a good talented all-rounder, but the flat decks of Australia could not be compared with the swinging pitches of England. Hence, another pace-bowling all-rounder in Pandya in the squad would have been an ideal option.

Verdict: The selectors could have named Pandya among the standbys as India is going for a large squad to manage the Covid bubble, and cover the possibility of injuries. But the selectors have not done so. It means India would have to manage with the resources available. India could miss Pandya whose brilliant fielding and positive attitude could have been an added bonus to the playing XI.

facebook whatsapp twitter linkedin

Check Also

Asia Cup

Asian Cricket Council Confirms Cancelled Asia Cup To Be Played In 2023

2 mins read : The cancelled Asia Cup 2021 will be held in 2023, the Asian Cricket Council (ACC) has confimred on Sunday.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FacebookInstagramLinkedInTwitter